Talk:Horace Mann

From Wikiquote
Jump to: navigation, search

This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Horace Mann page.


Unsourced[edit]

These should be provided with sources before being moved back into the article.
  • Teaching isn't one-tenth as effective as training.

Lost[edit]

The "Published as `A Beautiful Thought...'" explanation is very unclear. It implies that the quote is not by Horace Mann, and was misattributed to him by William Mathews in 1874. However, the phrasing "is often quoted as an advertisement originally written by Mann" seems to contradict this and imply that it is an advertisement originally written by Mann. This is supported by the fact that it is listed under Sourced, rather than Misattributed. As an aside, it also appears in "The True Briton," 1851, without attribution, as sent in by reader "R. B."

So what's the deal with this quote? Is it by Mann or not? Prignillius 20:30, 19 August 2011 (UTC)

The quotes about him aren't very representative[edit]

It seems odd that two of the three quotes by others about one of the foremost educators in American history should be somewhat conspiratorial and presentist takes on his desires to secularize education. One quotation of that sort from the present day seems sufficient to represent that point of view, but two out of three seems like it's stacking the deck. They hardly seems representative of the broad range of responses his ideas inspired and provoked. I'm sure his contemporaries had strong opinions of him or his ideas. Surely some other notables like John Dewey, Edward Thorndike, Booker T. Washington, Jane Addams, Louis Terman, Lev Vygotsky, Ivan Illich, or Herbert Kohl have had opinions of his impact. Present day historians and educators have plenty to say about him, given that he was such a towering figure in 19th century educational thought and practices. Why is so little of that here?