Talk:Jung Myung Seok
[edit] fair use
I argue they are fair use. The original material may or may not be copyright, but fair use applies to all copyright materials. They are for non-profit educational reasons and are only a small portion of the speeches.
RB972 08:47, 25 November 2006 (UTC)
While the veracity of many of these quotes may be verifiable, the intentions behind their publication are questionable when they lead to a non-biased website that exists for the sole purpose to oppose the individual in question. It's akin to anti-abortionists writing the wikipedia site on abortion. It presents a conflict of interest. [Meteditor]
I don't see how the full section on the holocaust quote changes the context at all. The quote is now too big, making the page harder to read.
Yes it matters who said it. But it says who did, a former follower. I don't see how it matters if their name was Todd or Jason or whatever. I noticed you deleted two critical quotes for this reason, but you didn't delete the positive quote. Please don't look for excuses to delete things. Also, there are many wikiquote pages that don't source all of their quotes.
I desire to revert the holocaust quote back to the shorter version to make the wikipedia more readable. Unless you can argue why it changes the context I will do so some time.
While I don't consider that the sole purpose of the website, the only reason that page is linked is that it is the only page that contains Jung's speeches. Of course I'd rather an official site, but JMS church produces no publicly available materials. RB972 05:39, 16 December 2006 (UTC)
Since you haven't discussed why you changed the hitler quote yet I know you've been active on wiki more than once, and I don't see any reason why the context changes it, I changed it back to a slightly larger version than the original. The old quote was far too long and was affecting the readability of the article. RB972 04:44, 18 December 2006 (UTC)
