Talk:The Lord of the Rings
At first I wondered how an empty page rated a link from the main page. So I added some quotes. Then I checked the history, realized that the page once held quotes and was divided into sub-pages. I had thought they were just links back to Wikipedia. At the least I think the list needs to explain where the bulk of the quotes are. I think a case can be made for having a selection of quotes on this page because the presence of the quotes from the preface makes it look unfinished or at least very unbalanced and because the complete quotes pages for each book are so extensive and hard to read through. That depends more on how you see the project though and I would not be upset to see them removed from here. But it should be more obvious where the quotes are. Rmhermen 04:41, 5 Aug 2004 (UTC)
Moving of quotes from the "Foreword"
I don't agree with the idea that the foreword should be given its own separate page. The Volumes themselves were given their own pages for reasons of length, and I can see a rationale to that, but the quotes from the foreword of the "second" edition were just a few general comments about the work as a whole, and I believe that they should remain here, behind the general links to the body of the work itself, because they were actually written years later, as is reflected by the very subject of the quotes, and there is simply no need for a separate page. ~ Achilles 13:03, 19 Jun 2005 (UTC)
- I concur. And there is another big change; see Talk:The Lord of the Rings (fandom) please. I don't think this type of fandom quotes passes our "notability" criteria. --Aphaia 20:08, 19 Jun 2005 (UTC)
Note that I didn't introduce the "fandom" quote, I just created a new section for them. But I agree that removing them (well, it, there's only one of them) is probably a much better move. About the foreword page I don't feel strongly either way. Jhi
Does anyone have the song they made when they thought Gandalf was dead?
- Err... What does this have to do with wikiquote?
- This can be an addition to wikiquote....because that was a significant moment in film. I am not sure if there is such song in books too. 22.214.171.124 21:31, 13 July 2010 (UTC)
- Err... What does this have to do with wikiquote?
Since this article has been added to Wikiquote:Good entries, I have been ruthless about restructuring and noting its sourcing failures. Most of the "sources" provided are too vague for any reasonable attempt at verifying them. I've also marked the "Forward to the Second Edition" section because a work as popular as LoTR probably has many editions and printings that include this forward, so we should have some specifics on at least one of them. I'm also concerned about the use of the term "portal", as we have no standards for such things here, but I'm more worried about the basics for now.
"Good articles" ought to be the best examples of well-formatted, well-sourced articles. Just as with Wikipedia's good- and featured-article system, nomination to this list should be a positive encouragement for improving articles to our highest standards (as opposed to Wikiquote's more traditional negative encouragement of VfD nomination). ~ Jeff Q (talk) 15:38, 14 March 2007 (UTC)
"Oh f--k, not another elf!"
Let's remove that nonsense.
- I agree... we don't need that crap here. And no, I am not a sock puppet, though I have no WQ contribs I have made numerous WP contribs, you can check for yourself. - Robodude2000 15:03, 23 September 2011 (UTC)
- Like the humor of it or not, this has become widely quoted, is well-sourced, and does belong in a compendium of notable quotes. ~ Kalki 02:46, 12 September 2009 (UTC)
What about quotes from the book?
Instead of just real world ones?
- Quotes for each of the books are provided on the pages which are linked prominently at the start of the page. ~ Kalki 02:44, 12 September 2009 (UTC)
moving Faramir here?
The page shows that a discussion is going about moving Faramir here. But I don't see any. So am starting one. I don't think it's a good idea. Because if we do that, we can run into trouble...we will have to move Gandalf, Frodo, Samwise Gamgee, Bilbo, Aragorn, Legolas, Gimli, Merryadoc, Peppin and many other pages here too. Besides, it makes no sense to move the character's quotations here...because then we can get in trouble with characters like Elrond and Gladriel, because they were mentioned outside LoTR too. And what about the quotes from The Hobbit? So, I think it's better if we keep characters' quotations separated. But you are welcome to include interesting dialogues from the books. Aarsalankhalid 21:40, 13 July 2010 (UTC)
- oops! I just realized that most of the pages don't exist! Then why the page about Faramir was created? Aarsalankhalid 21:43, 13 July 2010 (UTC)
- Why was any page created? Somebody thought it was a good idea at the time. Note that after Faramir was tagged for merging, a general policy for Fictional characters has been drafted, which indicates it is not such a good idea. To be clear, it would not be merged to this page per se, but to the listed articles on individual books. ~ Ningauble 13:18, 14 July 2010 (UTC)
i think we should move all the characters so we can fine em all
Yes, Move Him Here
Yup! Move all here!! Its easier to find them!
What's the year?
Review by C.S. Lewis, as quoted in The Essential J. R. R. Tolkien Sourcebook: A Fan's Guide to Middle-Earth and Beyond (2004) by George W. Beahm, p. 28
Here, however, we find the book was published in 2003: