Constitution of 3 May 1791: Difference between revisions

From Wikiquote
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Content deleted Content added
Piotrus (talk | contribs)
minor update
mNo edit summary
(11 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
About [[w:Polish Constitution of May 3, 1791|Polish Constitution of May 3, 1791]]:
Quotes about the '''[[w:Polish Constitution of May 3, 1791|Polish Constitution of May 3, 1791]]'''.


=== Contemporary ===
=== Contemporary ===
* King [[Stanislaw August Poniatowski|Stanisław August Poniatowski]] described the May 3rd Constitution, according to a contemporary account, as "founded principally on those of England and the United States of America, but avoiding the faults and errors of both, and adapt[ed] as much as possible to the local and particular circumstances of the country."
* The Prussian statesman [[Ewald von Hertzberg]] expressed the fears of European conservatives: "[The Poles] have given the ''coup de grâce'' to the Prussian monarchy by voting a constitution.… How can we defend our state… against a numerous and well-governed nation?"
* [[Hugo Kollataj|Hugo Kołłątaj]] and [[Ignacy Potocki]], two of the co-authors of the Constitution, termed it "the last will and testament of the expiring Fatherland."
* The Estabilishing Act of the Targowica Condeferation stated: "The intentions of Her Highness the [[Empress]] of [[Russia]] [Catherine the Great], ally of the Polish Commonwealth, in introducing her army, are and have been none other than to restore to the Commonwealth and to Poles freedom, and in particular to all the country's citizens, security and happiness."<!--Zamiary Naj. Imperatorowej rosyjskiej, aliantki Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej, nie inne s&#261; i by&#322;y, wprowadzaj&#261;c swe wojska, tylko przywróci&#263; Rzeczypospolitej Rzeczypospolit&#261;, Polakom wolno&#347;&#263;, a w szczególno&#347;ci wszystkim kraju obywatelom bezpiecze&#324;stwo i szcz&#281;&#347;liwo&#347;&#263;” Source: http://www.rodman.most.org.pl/J.T.Babel14.htm-->
* A co-founder of the Targowica Confederation, [[Stanislaw Szczesny Potocki|Stanis&#322;aw Szcz&#281;sny Potocki]] wrote: "Every true Pole who has not been inveigled by the Prussian and royalist cabal, is convinced that the Country's [[salvation]] can come only from [[Russia]], that otherwise the nation will be enslaved.." <!--„Ka&#380;dy prawdziwy Polak, którego nie uwiod&#322;a kaba&#322;a pruska i królewska, jest przekonany, &#380;e zbawienie ojczyzny mo&#380;e przyj&#347;&#263; tylko ze strony Rosji, inaczej naród zostanie zniewolony” (z korespondencji Szcz&#281;snego Potockiego, source and several others: http://www.rodman.most.org.pl/J.T.Babel14.htm--> After King [[Stanislaw August|Stanis&#322;aw August]]'s abdication and the demise of the Commonwealth, he wrote: "[I will speak no more] of the former Poland and the Poles. That country and that name are no more, as with so many others in the history of the world. I am now forever a Russian." <!-- o przesz&#322;ej Polsce i Polakach. Znik&#322;o ju&#380; to pa&#324;stwo, i to imi&#281;, jak znik&#322;o tyle innych w dziejach &#347;wiata. Ja ju&#380; jestem Rosjaninem na zawsze, same source as before-->
* [[Edmund Burke]] described the May 3rd Constitution as "so far as it had gone, it probably is the most pure and defacated public good which ever has been conferred on mankind. [It is] the noblest benefit received by any nation at any time.... Stanislas II [August Poniatowski] has earned a place among the greatest kings and statesmen in history."
* [[Thomas Jefferson]] expressed concern lest the American President, under the [[w:U.S. Constitution|U.S. Constitution]] drafted in 17, prove as impotent as Poland's elected king &mdash; "a bad edition of a Polish king."


* "[The] President seems a bad edition of a Polish King."
=== Later commentary ===
** [[Thomas Jefferson]] to [[John Adams]], 1787; on the office of American President under the draft U.S. Constitution, implying the President would prove as impotent as Poland's elected king [http://etext.virginia.edu/jefferson/quotations/jeff1230.htm]
* [[Karl Marx]] wrote of the Constitution: "Despite all its shortcomings, this Constitution looms against the background of Russian, Prussian and Austrian barbarism as the only work of liberty which Eastern Europe has ever created independently, and it emerged exclusively from the privileged class, from the nobility. The history of the world has never seen another example of such nobility of the nobility."

* On May 3, 1941, Sir [[Winston Churchill]] said in a radio address: "Today I am speaking to all the Poles all over the world. Today is the 150th anniversary of the Constitution passed by your parliament. Your are right to celebrate this day as a national holiday because, at the time when your Constitution of 1791 was drawn up, it was a model of enlightened political thought. The passing of that legal act was seen by your neighbours at that time as the dawn of a revival of the Polish state. Therefore they hurried to partition your country in order to prevent the consolidation of the Polish nation."
* "… founded principally on those of England and the United States of America, but avoiding the faults and errors of both, and adapt[ed] as much as possible to the local and particular circumstances of the country."
* Pope [[John Paul II]] in 1999 told the Polish Sejm: "It is difficult at this moment not to mention the long history of the Polish sejm, reaching back to the 15th century, or that glorious witness to the legislative wisdom of our ancestors that was the Constitution of May the Third, 1791." <!--Trudno w tej chwili nie wspomnie&#263; o d&#322;ugiej, si&#281;gaj&#261;cej XV w. historii polskiego Sejmu czy te&#380; o chlubnym &#347;wiadectwie ustawodawczej m&#261;dro&#347;ci naszych przodków, jakim by&#322;a Konstytucja 3 maja z 1791 r., source: http://serwisy.gazeta.pl/swiat/1,63965,2611223.html-->
** King [[Stanis&#322;aw August]], according to a contemporary American newspaper account; describing the May 3rd Constitution

* "[It is] the noblest benefit ever received by any nation at any time. […] Stanislas II has earned a place among the greatest kings and statesmen in history."
** [[Edmund Burke]], in response to [[w:Prussia|Prussian]] statesman [[Ewald von Hertzberg]]'s expression of the fears of European conservatives: "[The Poles] have given the ''coup de grâce'' to the Prussian monarchy by voting a constitution. […] How can we defend our state… against a numerous and well-governed nation?"

* "The intentions of Her Highness the Empress of Russia [Catherine the Great], ally of the Polish Commonwealth, in introducing her army, are and have been none other than to restore to the Commonwealth and to Poles freedom, and in particular to all the country's citizens, security and happiness."
** Original: "Zamiary Naj. Imperatorowej rosyjskiej, aliantki Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej, nie inne s&#261; i by&#322;y, wprowadzaj&#261;c swe wojska, tylko przywróci&#263; Rzeczypospolitej Rzeczypospolit&#261;, Polakom wolno&#347;&#263;, a w szczególno&#347;ci wszystkim kraju obywatelom bezpiecze&#324;stwo i szcz&#281;&#347;liwo&#347;&#263;"
** The Establishing Act of the Targowica Confederation [http://www.rodman.most.org.pl/J.T.Babel14.htm]

* "Every true Pole who has not been inveigled by the Prussian and royalist cabal, is convinced that the Country's salvation can come only from Russia, that otherwise the nation will be enslaved."
** Original: "Ka&#380;dy prawdziwy Polak, którego nie uwiod&#322;a kaba&#322;a pruska i królewska, jest przekonany, &#380;e zbawienie ojczyzny mo&#380;e przyj&#347;&#263; tylko ze strony Rosji, inaczej naród zostanie zniewolony"
** [[Stanislaw Szczesny Potocki|Stanis&#322;aw Szcz&#281;sny Potocki]], co-founder of the Targowica Confederation
** [http://www.rodman.most.org.pl/J.T.Babel14.htm ''Z korespondencji Szcz&#281;snego Potockiego'']

* "[I will speak no more] of the former Poland and the Poles. That country and that name are no more, as with so many others in the history of the world. I am now forever a Russian."
** Original: "o przesz&#322;ej Polsce i Polakach. Znik&#322;o ju&#380; to pa&#324;stwo, i to imi&#281;, jak znik&#322;o tyle innych w dziejach &#347;wiata. Ja ju&#380; jestem Rosjaninem na zawsze"
** [[Stanis&#322;aw Szcz&#281;sny Potocki]], after Stanis&#322;aw August's abdication and the demise of the Commonwealth
** ''Z korespondencji Szcz&#281;snego Potockiego''

* "… the last will and testament of the expiring Fatherland."
** [[Hugo Ko&#322;&#322;&#261;taj]] and [[Ignacy Potocki]], two of the Constitution's authors, writing in exile after the Targowica Confederation's victory
** ''On the Adoption and Fall of the Polish May 3rd Constitution'' (1793)

=== Later ===

* "Despite all its shortcomings, this Constitution looms up against the background of Russian, Prussian and Austrian barbarism as the only work of liberty which Eastern Europe has ever created independently, and it emerged exclusively from the privileged class, from the nobility. The history of the world has never seen another example of such nobility of the nobility."
** [[Karl Marx]]

* "Today I am speaking to all the Poles all over the world. Today is the 150th anniversary of the Constitution passed by your parliament. You are right to celebrate this day as a national holiday because, at the time when your Constitution of 1791 was drawn up, it was a model of enlightened political thought. The passing of that legal act was seen by your neighbours at that time as a dawn of a revival of the Polish state. Therefore they hurried to partition your country in order to prevent the consolidation of the Polish nation."
** British Prime Minister [[Winston Churchill]], 3 May 1941 radio address

* "It is difficult at this moment not to mention the long history of the Polish Sejm, reaching back to the 15th century, or that glorious witness to the legislative wisdom of our ancestors that was the Constitution of May the Third, 1791."
** Original: "Trudno w tej chwili nie wspomnie&#263; o d&#322;ugiej, si&#281;gaj&#261;cej XV w. historii polskiego Sejmu czy te&#380; o chlubnym &#347;wiadectwie ustawodawczej m&#261;dro&#347;ci naszych przodków, jakim by&#322;a Konstytucja 3 maja z 1791 r."
** Pope [[John Paul II]], 1999, to the Polish Sejm [http://serwisy.gazeta.pl/swiat/1,63965,2611223.html]

[[Category:Politics]]

Revision as of 04:03, 16 October 2005

Quotes about the Polish Constitution of May 3, 1791.

Contemporary

  • "[The] President seems a bad edition of a Polish King."
    • Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 1787; on the office of American President under the draft U.S. Constitution, implying the President would prove as impotent as Poland's elected king [1]
  • "… founded principally on those of England and the United States of America, but avoiding the faults and errors of both, and adapt[ed] as much as possible to the local and particular circumstances of the country."
    • King Stanisław August, according to a contemporary American newspaper account; describing the May 3rd Constitution
  • "[It is] the noblest benefit ever received by any nation at any time. […] Stanislas II has earned a place among the greatest kings and statesmen in history."
    • Edmund Burke, in response to Prussian statesman Ewald von Hertzberg's expression of the fears of European conservatives: "[The Poles] have given the coup de grâce to the Prussian monarchy by voting a constitution. […] How can we defend our state… against a numerous and well-governed nation?"
  • "The intentions of Her Highness the Empress of Russia [Catherine the Great], ally of the Polish Commonwealth, in introducing her army, are and have been none other than to restore to the Commonwealth and to Poles freedom, and in particular to all the country's citizens, security and happiness."
    • Original: "Zamiary Naj. Imperatorowej rosyjskiej, aliantki Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej, nie inne są i były, wprowadzając swe wojska, tylko przywrócić Rzeczypospolitej Rzeczypospolitą, Polakom wolność, a w szczególności wszystkim kraju obywatelom bezpieczeństwo i szczęśliwość"
    • The Establishing Act of the Targowica Confederation [2]
  • "Every true Pole who has not been inveigled by the Prussian and royalist cabal, is convinced that the Country's salvation can come only from Russia, that otherwise the nation will be enslaved."
  • "[I will speak no more] of the former Poland and the Poles. That country and that name are no more, as with so many others in the history of the world. I am now forever a Russian."
    • Original: "o przeszłej Polsce i Polakach. Znikło już to państwo, i to imię, jak znikło tyle innych w dziejach świata. Ja już jestem Rosjaninem na zawsze"
    • Stanisław Szczęsny Potocki, after Stanisław August's abdication and the demise of the Commonwealth
    • Z korespondencji Szczęsnego Potockiego
  • "… the last will and testament of the expiring Fatherland."
    • Hugo Kołłątaj and Ignacy Potocki, two of the Constitution's authors, writing in exile after the Targowica Confederation's victory
    • On the Adoption and Fall of the Polish May 3rd Constitution (1793)

Later

  • "Despite all its shortcomings, this Constitution looms up against the background of Russian, Prussian and Austrian barbarism as the only work of liberty which Eastern Europe has ever created independently, and it emerged exclusively from the privileged class, from the nobility. The history of the world has never seen another example of such nobility of the nobility."
  • "Today I am speaking to all the Poles all over the world. Today is the 150th anniversary of the Constitution passed by your parliament. You are right to celebrate this day as a national holiday because, at the time when your Constitution of 1791 was drawn up, it was a model of enlightened political thought. The passing of that legal act was seen by your neighbours at that time as a dawn of a revival of the Polish state. Therefore they hurried to partition your country in order to prevent the consolidation of the Polish nation."
  • "It is difficult at this moment not to mention the long history of the Polish Sejm, reaching back to the 15th century, or that glorious witness to the legislative wisdom of our ancestors that was the Constitution of May the Third, 1791."
    • Original: "Trudno w tej chwili nie wspomnieć o długiej, sięgającej XV w. historii polskiego Sejmu czy też o chlubnym świadectwie ustawodawczej mądrości naszych przodków, jakim była Konstytucja 3 maja z 1791 r."
    • Pope John Paul II, 1999, to the Polish Sejm [3]