# André Weil

Jump to navigation
Jump to search

**André Weil** (6 May 1906 – 6 August 1998) was one of the greatest mathematicians of the 20th century, whether measured by his research work, its influence on future work, exposition or breadth. He is known for his foundational work in number theory and algebraic geometry. He was a founding member, and *de facto* the early leader, of the influential Bourbaki group. The philosopher Simone Weil was his sister.

This article about a mathematician is a stub. You can help Wikiquote by expanding it. |

## Quotes[edit]

- ... the geometry over
*p*-adic fields, and more generally over complete local rings, can provide us only with local data; and the main tasks of algebraic geometry have always been understood to be of a global nature. It is well known that there can be no global theory of algebraic varieties unless one makes them "complete", by adding to them suitable "points at infinity," embedding them, for example, in projective spaces. In the theory of curves, for instance, one would not otherwise obtain such basic facts as that the number of poles and zeros of a function are equal, of that the sum of residues of a differential is 0.- "Number-theory and algebraic geometry." In
*Proc. Intern. Math. Congress*, Cambridge, Mass. , vol. 2, pp. 90–100. 1950. (quote from p. 94)

- "Number-theory and algebraic geometry." In

**God exists since mathematics is consistent, and the Devil exists since we cannot prove it.**- As quoted in
*Mathematical Circles Adieu*(Boston 1977) by H Eves

- As quoted in

**First rank scientists recruit first rank scientists, but second rank scientists tend to recruit third rank scientists**, third rank scientists recruit fifth rank, and so on. If the director of the Department is genuinely interested in preserving the high quality of his Institute, he must exercise all of his power to put things in their right place, otherwise the deterioration process is destined to diverge indefinitely.- As quoted in
*Comic Sections*(Dublin 1993) by D MacHale

- As quoted in

- An important point is that the
*p*-adic field, or respectively the real or complex field, corresponding to a prime ideal, plays exactly the role, in arithmetic, that the field of power series*in the neighborhood of a point*plays in the theory of functions: that is why one calls it a*local field*.- as translated by Martin H. Krieger "A 1940 letter of André Weil on analogy in mathematics." Notices of the AMS 52, no. 3 (2005) pp. 334–341, quote on p. 340

- It is hard for you to appreciate that modern mathematics has become so extensive and so complex that it is essential,
*if*mathematics is to stay as a whole and not become a pile of little bits of research, to provide a unification, which absorbs in some simple and general theories all the common substrata of the diverse branches if the science, suppressing what is not so useful and necessary, and leaving intact what is truly the specific detail of each big problem. This is the good one can achieve with axiomatics (and this is no small achievement). This is what Bourbaki is up to.- as translated by Martin H. Krieger "A 1940 letter of André Weil on analogy in mathematics." Notices of the AMS 52, no. 3 (2005) pp. 334–341, quote on p. 341

- About ancient mathematics (whether Greek or Mesopotamian) and medieval mathematics (Western or Oriental), the would-be historian must of necessity confine himself to the description of a comparatively small number of islands accidentally emerging from an ocean of ignorance, and to tenuous conjectural reconstructions of the submerged continents which at one time must have bridged the gaps between them.

*The Apprenticeship of a Mathematician (1992)*[edit]

- Every mathematician worthy of the name has experienced, if only rarely,
**the state of lucid exaltation in which one thought succeeds another as if miraculously, and in which the unconscious (however one interprets this word) seems to play a role**. In a famous passage, Poincaré describes how he discovered Fuchsian functions in such a moment. About such states, Gauss is said to have remarked as follows: "*Procreare jucundum*(to conceive is a pleasure)"; he added, however, "*sed parturire molestum*(but to give birth is painful)." Unlike sexual pleasure, this feeling may last for hours at a time, even for days. Once you have experienced it, you are eager to repeat it but unable to do so at will, unless perhaps by dogged work which it seems to reward with its appearance. It is true that the pleasure experienced is not necessarily in proportion with the value of the discoveries with which it is associated.- p. 91

- In comparison with the wise man, the saint is perhaps just a specialist - a specialist in holiness; whereas the wise man has no specialty. This is not to say, far from it, that Dehn was not a mathematician of great talent; he left behind a body of work of very high quality. But
**for such a man, truth is all one, and mathematics is but one of the mirrors in which it is reflected - perhaps more purely than it is elsewhere.**- p. 52

- Hopf, back from Amsterdam, was teaching Brouwer's topology. He had helped arrange lodgings for me quite close to where he lived, rather far from the center of town, and together we would take the long tram ride to the university. One day I asked him what he would do when he got tired of topology. He replied in all seriousness: "But I'll never get tired of topology!"
- p. 53

- I began to combine this ordinary form of touring with a specifically mathematical variety. I had formed the ambition of becoming, like Hadamard, a "universal" mathematician: the way I expressed it was that I wished to know more than non-specialists and less than specialists about every mathematical topic. Naturally, I did not achieve either goal.
- p. 55

- Is it mere coincidence that in India Pāṇini's invention of grammar had preceded that of decimal notation and negative numbers, and that later on, both grammar and algebra reached the unparalleled heights for which the medieval civilization of the Arabic-speaking world is known?
- p. 20

- Both the Jews and the brahmins of southern India are communities that, for twenty centuries, have devoted themselves tirelessly to the most abstract subtleties of grammar and theology. For the Jews it was the study of the Talmud, a task often passed down from father to son; for the brahmins, it was the Brahmanas and the Upanishads. It is hardly surprising that the younger generations, when their time came, turned toward the sciences, and preferably the most abstract among them: this trend was merely the natural extension of millennial traditions.
- p. 80

- [On meeting Raymond Paley] At first, we seemed to be on completely different wavelengths. Finally, it became apparent to me that
**he worked fruitfully only when competing with others: having the rest of the pack at his side spurred him to greater efforts as he tried to surpass them. In contrast, my style was to seek out topics that I felt exposed me to no competition whatsoever, leaving me free to reflect undisturbed for years.**No doubt every scientific discipline has room for such differences of temperament. What does it matter if a given researcher is motivated primarily by hopes of winning the Nobel prize? Sometimes it seems to me that Ganesh, the Hindu god of knowledge, chooses the bait, noble or vulgar, best suited to each of his followers.- p. 94

- I had also, unsuccessfully, looked for the works of Saint John of the Cross. The flashing beauty of his poems would probably have moved me more than did Saint Theresa, but it was not until much later that I came to know his work. I read a little of Saint Theresa and became quickly convinced that
**mystic thought is at bottom the same in all times and places**: reading Suzuki's popular works on Zen was soon to confirm this conclusion. ... Speaking of a saint whose behavior was somewhat eccentric, one of the monks remarked gently: "But Christianity is madness" ("*el cristianismo es una locum*"). This perfectly orthodox statement often comes to mind when I think about my sister's life.- p. 99

- Awaiting me upon my return to Strasbourg were Henri Cartan and the course on "differential and integral calculus," which was our joint responsibility. ... One point that concerned him was
**the****degree to which we should generalize Stokes' formula in our teaching**. ... In his book on invariant integrals, Elie Cartan, following Poincare in emphasizing the importance of this formula,**proposed to extend its domain of validity. Mathematically speaking, the question was of a depth that far exceeded what we were in a position to suspect**. ... One winter day toward the end of 1934,1 thought of a brilliant way of putting an end to my friend's persistent questioning. We had several friends who were responsible for teaching the same topics in various universities. "Why don't we get together and settle such matters once and for all, and you won't plague me with your questions any more?" Little did I know that at that moment Bourbaki was born.- p. 99-100

- [Otto Schmidt] called together the principal mathematicians in Moscow and Petrograd (later known as Leningrad) and spoke to them more or less as follows: "Whatever the regime, the work of mathematicians is too inaccessible to laymen for us to be criticized from the outside; as long as we stick together, we will remain invulnerable."
- p. 108

- The major classic texts in analysis (Jordan, Goursat) which we had at first set out to replace aimed to set forth in a few volumes everything a beginning mathematician should know before specializing. At the end of the nineteenth century, such a claim could still be made seriously; by now it had become absurd. ... it soon became apparent that there was no alternative but to give up any idea of writing a text for college-level instruction.
**Above all it was important to lay a foundation that was broad enough to support the essential core of modern mathematics**...- p. 113

- In establishing the tasks to be undertaken by Bourbaki, significant progress was made with the adoption of the notion of
**structure**, and of the related notion of**isomorphism**. Retrospectively these two concepts seem ordinary and rather short on mathematical content, unless the notions of morphism and category are added.**At the time of our early work these notions cast new light upon subjects which were still shrouded in confusion: even the meaning of the term "isomorphism" varied from one theory to another.**That there were simple structures of group, of topological space, etc., and then also more complex structures, from rings to fields, had not to my knowledge been said by anyone before Bourbaki, and it was something that needed to be said. As for the choice of the word "structure," my memory fails me; but at that time, I believe, it had already entered the working vocabulary of linguists, a milieu with which I had maintained ties (in particular with Émile Benveniste).- p. 114

- Kantian ethic, or what passes for it today, has always seemed to me to be the height of arrogance and folly. Claiming always to behave according to the precepts of universal maxims is either totally inept or totally hypocritical; one can always find a maxim to justify whatever behavior one chooses. I could not count the times (for example, when I tell people I never vote in elections) that I have heard the objection: "But if everyone were to behave like you..." - to which I usually reply that this possibility seems to me so implausible that I do not feel obligated to take it into account.
- p. 124

- Already while at the Ecole Normale, I had been deeply struck by the damage wreaked upon mathematics in France by World War I. This war had created a vacuum that my own and subsequent generations were hard pressed to fill.
**In 1914, the Germans had wisely sought to spare the cream of their young scientific elite and, to a large extent, these people had been sheltered. In France a misguided notion of equality in the face of sacrifice - no doubt praiseworthy in intent - had led to the opposite policy,**whose disastrous consequences can be read, for example, on the monument to the dead of the Ecole Normale. Those were cruel losses; but there was more besides. Four or more years of military life, whether close to death or far away from it - but in any case far from science -, are not good preparation for resuming the scientific life: very few of those who survived returned to science with the keenness they had felt for it. This was a fate that I thought it my duty, or rather my dharma, to avoid.- p. 126

- Mozart's music, even at its most beautiful, often gives an impression of some being who, though very far above us in his incomprehensible serenity, nevertheless stops to remember us for a brief instant and comes within our reach, with gentle mockery and tender pity, to transcribe a fleeting message for us. But sometimes, in certain quartets and quintets, and in certain parts of The Magic Flute, this same being, without a thought for us, communicates with his fellow beings, and what we hear then is a world unknown to us, a world of which we are allowed only a furtive glimpse.
- p. 132

- (April 7) My mathematics work is proceeding beyond my wildest hopes, and I am even a bit worried -
**if it's only in prison that I work so well, will I have to arrange to spend two or three months locked up every year?**In the meantime, I am contemplating writing a report to the proper authorities, as follows: "To the Director of Scientific Research: Having recently been in a position to discover through personal experience the considerable advantages afforded to pure and distinterested research by a stay in the establishments of the Penitentiary System, I take the liberty of, etc. etc."- p. 146. in a letter written to his wife from Rouen prison.

- One day it occurred to me to measure the speed with which such rumors were propagated. All I had to do was to start one - the more preposterous the better - at one end of the stadium, and then hasten to the other end to await the results.
- p. 160

## Quotes About[edit]

- Alexandre Grothendieck was very different from Weil in the way he approached mathematics: Grothendieck was not just a mathematician who could understand the discipline and prove important results—he was a man who could
*create*mathematics. And he did it alone.- Amir D. Aczel (29 April 2009).
*The Artist and the Mathematician*. Basic Books. pp. 54. ISBN 978-0-7867-3288-3.

- Amir D. Aczel (29 April 2009).

- In his thesis, Weil generalized Mordell's theorem on the finite generation of the group of rational points on an elliptic curve, to abelian varieties of any dimension. Weil then hoped to use this finite generation result for the rational points on the jacobian of a curve to go on to show that when a curve of genus > 1 is imbedded in its jacobian, only a finite number of the rational points of the jacobian can lie on the curve. Not finding a way to do this, he decided to call his proof of finite generation (the "theorem of Mordell-Weill") a thesis, despite Hadamard's advice not to be satisfied with half a result!
- Barry Mazur: "On Some of the Mathematical Contributions of Gerd Faltings".
*Proceedings of the International Congress of Mathematicians, Berkeley, 1986*.**vol. 1**. pp. 7–12. (quote from p. 7)

- Barry Mazur: "On Some of the Mathematical Contributions of Gerd Faltings".

*At Home with André and Simone Weil* (2010)[edit]

- Sometimes my sister and I dream of having a run-of-the-mill father. He would make coffee and toss salads. He would not prefer his work to us, and he would tell us instead: "How pretty you look, my dear, tell me what you did today." He would speak to us with words of affectionate banality.

- Yes, but there is the problem. It would have been banal. Mediocre. We had been trained to despise everything which was not excellent. How disgusting to see the father of one of our classmates or friends on vacation playing cards or, even worse, sitting on the sofa watching television. We blush with shame for our unfortunate little friend.
- From
*At home with André and Simone Weil*by Sylvie Weil, p. 30 (translated by Benjamin Ivry)

- From

- When he was not busy doing math, he reads fat books covered with rough leather, on the pages of which can be seen very old, perfectly round holes dug out by medieval worms. Or else he passes through a museum while devoting himself to unbelievably profound notions about Van Gogh's paintings or Greek amphorae.

- For our genius of a father did not limit himself to math. His brain was an octopus, the tentacles of which extended in all directions. He could scan Latin verse and Greek verse as well, and it was as if he were hearing Homer or Theocritus in person. Not to mention the fact that he read Greek from volumes filled with characters which in no way resembled the ones in our Greek grammar or book of excerpts from Greek literature. He also read Sanskrit, with its truly bizarre letters. He spoke Italian like Dante, Spanish like Cervantes, and so for almost every living language.

## External links[edit]

- "André Weil",
*at the MacTutor History of Mathematics archive* - André Weil : memorial articles in the Notices of the American Mathematical Society
- A 1940 Letter of André Weil on Analogy in Mathematics
- "Andre Weil, Who Reshaped Mathematics, Is Dead at 92" by Ford Burkhart in
*The New York Times*(10 August 1998) - "The lives they lived: Andre Weil; Numbers Man" by Paul Hoffman in
*The New York Times*(3 January 1999) - Artless innocents and ivory-tower sophisticates: Some personalities on the Indian mathematical scene by M. S. Raghunathan
- Image of Weil