Talk:Edgar Allan Poe

From Wikiquote
Jump to: navigation, search

Images[edit]

I have to say that I disagree with using all these images; some are not intentionally illustrative of Poe's words and some do not necessarily reflect them. The image of Poe's wife, for example, includes a quote from a poem written two years before their marriage - putting the quote as the caption implies that the lines are about her, which is not true. --71.225.104.186 17:56, 29 April 2008 (UTC)

I'm going to bring this up again because my previous attempt at editing was reverted: Some of these images are not related to Poe. Some of these captions are not related to their image. Some examples: quoting a poem Poe wrote one he was 15 with an image of him at 39? Quoting a poem under the image of Poe's wife when the poem was written two years before they were engaged (thereby suggesting the poem was about her, even though it clearly is not)? Quoting "Annabel Lee" with an image of Sarah Elmira Royster (when several women could claim inspiration)? A statue of El Cid with a quote from Eldorado? Using I have seen no other page on Wikiquote with this kind of problem... why are we setting a precedent with Poe? This is, frankly, disappointing and shameful. --71.225.104.186 18:48, 30 April 2008 (UTC)
I hadn't realized it was a standard practice to use quotes in the main image (my first check was on Mark Twain, who does not follow this practice). Even so, the entire quote page is very POV, pushing the dark, horror, scary side of Poe as someone who was demented, different, and obsessed with death (the quotes about Poe in particular push this). Why not quote something that is more than just the mainstream image of Poe, and focus on the beauty of his work, rather than the darkness and horror he is perceived as embodying? (As an aside, I have personally brought the wikipedia article on Edgar Allan Poe to featured article and have the tendency to consider myself an expert... a poem he wrote when he was 15 does not sum up the man well at all). Here's an alternative suggestion, using his own words rather than fiction: "After all... Literature is the most noble of professions. In fact, it is about the only one fit for a man. For my own part, there is no seducing me from the path." -Letter from Poe to Frederick W. Thomas, February 1849. --71.225.104.186 21:19, 30 April 2008 (UTC)
Your suggestion for the first caption sounds good to me. As for your point about the types of quotes that appear here, if you have others that are properly sourced and reflect another side of him, feel free to add them. Your point above about the appropriateness of using certain quotes as captions, again if you have others that might be better served as captions, feel free to change them. ~ UDScott 16:10, 1 May 2008 (UTC)

Unsourced[edit]

Wikiquote no longer allows unsourced quotations, and they are in process of being removed from our pages (see Wikiquote:Limits on quotations); but if you can provide a reliable and precise source for any quote on this list please move it to Edgar Allan Poe. --Antiquary 19:21, 27 March 2009 (UTC)

  • No man who ever lived knows any more about the hereafter ... than you and I; and all religion ... is simply evolved out of chicanery, fear, greed, imagination and poetry.
  • The idea of God, infinity, or spirit stands for the possible attempt at an impossible conception.
  • The pioneers and missionaries of religion have been the real cause of more trouble and war than all other classes of mankind.
  • Beauty of whatever kind, in its supreme development, invariably excites the sensitive soul to tears.
  • I became insane, with long intervals of horrible sanity.
  • I have become insane with random intervals of horrible sanity.
  • I don't believe in ghosts but they have been chasing me my whole life.
  • Experience has shown, and a true philosophy will always show, that a vast, perhaps the larger, portion of the truth arises from the seemingly irrelevant.

Sleep[edit]

“Sleep, those little slices of death—how I loathe them.” This is widely attributed to Poe, possibly because Nightmare on Elm Street 3 claimed so, but there doesn’t seem to be any record of his ever having said this. But should it be mentioned in here? What is Wikiquote's policy on false attributions? Correct them? Ignore them and let them persist? —173.199.215.5 22:30, 3 March 2014 (UTC)

I found the FAQ and I’m adding the quote per Wikiquote:FAQ#Misattributions. Thanks. —173.199.215.5 22:35, 3 March 2014 (UTC)