Talk:Vedanga Jyotisha

Surplus

• Some scholars seem very unwilling to stray too far from the chronological security of the explicit statement in the Vedangajyotisa that places the vernal equinox in 10 degrees of Bharani, the winter solstice in the beginning of Sravistha, the summer solstice in the middle of Aslesa, and the autumnal equinox in 3 degrees of Visakhd. Astronomers have assigned this conjunction dates ranging from 1391 to 1181 B.C.E. (Keith [1912] 1967, 423) Even this text, since the time of Max Muller (1892, xxix) and despite containing such specific information regarding the position of all four equinoctial and solsticial points, has not been unanimously accepted as a reliable record of the second millennium B.C.E. Whitney, like Thibaut, also questions the correspondence of the naksatras mentioned in the Vedangajyotisa to the equal 1 3Vz degree divisions they de- noted in later times.
  • in Bryant, E. F. (2001). The Quest for the Origins of Vedic Culture : the Indo-Aryan migration debate. Oxford University Press. chapter 12

• Accordingly, Kak (1994b) adjusts the latitude of thirty-five degrees to account for refraction, so that "after corrections are made this corresponds to a latitude of thirty-four degrees which is correct for northwest India to the North of the Sarasvati valleys" (101). Since this ratio is applicable to Northwest India, he considers it perfectly acceptable to propose that the Vedangajyotisa could have been composed in this latitude. This view has received support from Yukio Ohashi (1997), who believes that "it is clear that this formula is based on the observation in North India" and more specifically the "Kashmir area, and much north of the basin of the Ganga River which was the central area in post-Vedic period [sic]." According to yet another astronomer, Narahari Achar, "It does not follow that India borrowed from Mesopotamia, or, for that matter, Mesopotamia borrowed from India; nothing precluded the possibility of parallel development in both countries independent of each other." More important, he notes that "a ratio of 2:1 for the duration of the longest day to the shortest day was used in the early days of Mesopotamia and was only modified to the value 3:2."39
  • in Bryant, E. F. (2001). The Quest for the Origins of Vedic Culture : the Indo-Aryan migration debate. Oxford University Press. chapter 12

• I see no reason to doubt Achar's second paper (2000) regarding the date of Joytisa Vedánga. Here evidence is provided that an astronomical reference in this text is not of a date c 400 as some western scholars think, nor of c 1300 as others claim (identifying the star Dhanistha with beta Delphini) but c 1800, when Dhanistha, now identified with delta Capricorn, receives sun and moon together for the winter solstice (Achar 2000:177).
  • Kazanas, N. (2002). Indigenous Indo-Aryans and the Rigveda: Indo-Aryan migration debate. Journal of Indo-European Studies, 30(3-4), 275-334.